Fantasy football trophies

Fantasy football trophies are more than decoration—they’re what make your league feel real. A great trophy turns your competition into a lasting tradition, gives every team something to fight for, and brings your league’s story to life. If you’re setting up your first league trophy (or upgrading from a cheap plastic one), here’s how to choose the perfect one for your group.

1. Pick a trophy that fits your league’s personality

Start by thinking about your league’s vibe:

• Serious competitors: Go with a classic metal cup or engraved crystal award that screams “champion.”
• Comedic leagues: Try a funny or themed trophy—toilet bowls, bobbleheads, and golden footballs are popular choices.
• Casual or family leagues: A lightweight resin or acrylic trophy works great and still looks impressive.

If you want something that lasts for years, choose a perpetual trophy—a large base with room for engraved plates for each season’s winner.

2. Consider customization and materials

Personalized touches make the trophy special. You can:

• Add your league name and champion year
• Include your league logo or team icons
• Choose engraved plates for each winner

Shops like Artemis Awards and Apparel in Mentor, Ohio, can design custom fantasy football trophies that match your league’s style—metal, resin, glass, or wood—with fast turnaround and no order minimums.

3. Don’t forget the “loser” trophy

Adding a last-place trophy makes every matchup matter. Funny ideas include:

• A golden toilet
• A crying baby plaque
• A pink purse or tutu-themed trophy

Many leagues even make losers display their trophy until the next season—just to keep things competitive and fun.

4. Think long-term

Choose a trophy that will last. A sturdy, engravable base lets you keep adding winner names every year, turning it into a living history of your league. You can even order extra plates in advance for future seasons to save time.

5. Where to buy

• Artemis Awards and Apparel (Mentor, OH and Highland Heights, OH): Fully custom fantasy football trophies, plaques, and engraving with no minimum order.
• Crown Awards & Trophies: Big online selection, but less personalization.
• Etsy: Great for unique or handmade designs, though turnaround can vary.